top of page

'Faust' as Pretext: The Self in the Mirror and Theatrum Mundi at La Scala

Poza scriitorului: Luca Paula Margareta
Luca Paula Margareta
acum 1 minut
26 min de citit

Faust by Charles Gounod, the final operatic production of Teatro alla Scala’s 2025-2026 season, reached the public only after a path far from free of difficulties. The premiere, originally scheduled earlier, was cancelled due to labor actions that disrupted the theatre’s activities, and the rescheduling of the performances generated intense anticipation, further heightening public interest in the new production. For an institution with La Scala’s history, such episodes are not an absolute exception but rather one of the inevitable realities of a living theatre situated at the intersection of tradition, contemporary relevance, and the pressures of the modern world. The theatre’s recent history offers pertinent precedents: in 2010, Gounod’s Faust was also affected by labor disputes that led to the cancellation of several performances.


The performance of 8 November 2026, filmed and broadcast for audiences far beyond the Milanese auditorium, thus acquired a particular significance. It became not merely the final stage in the journey of the season’s last operatic production, but an event that extended its life and its encounter with audiences beyond the theatre’s walls. The recording remained available on Scala TV for a further 168 hours after the final curtain fell. Yet the evening’s real surprise lay not in the circumstances surrounding the production, but in the way the performance transcended the traditional reading of Gounod’s opera. This was not only a story about Faust and the consequences of his choices, about pact, temptation, love, and damnation. It was also a story about theatre itself, reintroduced into the collective imagination through an artistic construction in which the cast became part of a much broader mechanism of representation.

Vittorio Grigolo as Faust – Faust at Teatro alla Scala (image adapted from the official trailer)
Vittorio Grigolo as Faust – Faust at Teatro alla Scala (image adapted from the official trailer)

The cast brought together performers of distinctly individual vocal personalities: Marina Rebeka (Marguerite), Vittorio Grigolo (Faust), and Alex Esposito (Méphistophélès), alongside Ernesto Petti (Valentin), Marcela Rahal (Siébel), Hyeonsol Park (Marthe), and Xhieldo Hyseni (Wagner). They were joined by the Orchestra del Teatro alla Scala, conducted by Daniele Rustioni, and the Coro del Teatro alla Scala, prepared by chorus master Alberto Malazzi. The staging was created as a co-production with the Palau de les Arts Reina Sofía in Valencia, the Staatsoper Unter den Linden in Berlin, and the Teatro Real in Madrid.


The production also marked the La Scala directorial debut of Johannes Erath. Trained within Vienna’s musical milieu and active on major European stages, the director appears to have conceived a reading built around dreams and the oneiric. The movement of the characters across the stage, the constant transfer of space and theatrical convention, as well as the objects that accompany them, support this perspective: Faust’s writing slate, the poisoned cup, Marguerite’s white parasol, Valentin’s balloon, Méphistophélès’ magic cane, a theatre seat from Row Three, or the Vitruvian Man inscribed within a clock face. Taken together, these elements seem to construct less a dreamscape than a reading through the lens of Theatrum Mundi, transforming the theatrical institution itself into a character within the drama, alongside its memories and ghosts.


The set design echoes and reflects the architecture of La Scala itself, and in Act III, through Salut! demeure chaste et pure, it blurs the boundary between audience and performance, reality and fiction. Although the device is not new, it is given an authentic dramatic function, largely avoiding the trap of self-referentiality through its simultaneous evocation of Parisian theatre interiors. Yet clear limitations also emerge within this construction. Johannes Erath begins from a fertile idea, that of theatre contemplating itself, but does not always succeed in disciplining it dramatically. The proliferation of symbols, the constant presence of doubles, the accumulation of allegorical objects, and the repeated use of video projections occasionally create the impression of a scenic imagination unwilling to submit to the discipline of selection. Many images are seductive in themselves without always proving necessary to the development of the conflict. What the production gains in conceptual richness, it sometimes loses in dramatic clarity. The performance impresses through its intelligence, yet does not always reach that theatrical simplicity in which the symbol ceases to be a quotation. Or perhaps this perpetual invitation to interpretation is itself one of the director’s fundamental choices.


Within this mechanism, the Cup of Youth becomes a central axis. It halts the movement of rotation, restores dormant souls to life, and projects members of the chorus into the background, from figures distant in time to modern characters. Time acquires a circular configuration in which the passage between generations, the succession of recurring patterns, and the suspension of the instant coexist with the idea of irreversibility. The first and last scenes mirror one another in a dramaturgical structure governed by light. Faust’s pact ceases to concern solely the destiny of an individual and becomes a reflection on the power of theatrical illusion itself. The characters appear trapped within a space that constantly observes and judges them, while the mirrors incorporated into the set multiply identities and suggest the fragility of the border between appearance and truth.


The set designed by Heike Scheele exploits, among other things, the architecture of the Milanese auditorium without succumbing to mere fascination with its monumentality. Fabio Antoci’s lighting subtly shapes the transition between reality and imagination, while Bibi Abel’s video projections bring the singers’ expressions closer to every spectator, functioning more as a means of amplification than as decorative effect. The costumes by Gesine Völlm avoid strict historical reconstruction, particularly in the treatment of the collective characters, and place the protagonists within a timeless world suspended between memory and representation.


If the production functions, it is above all because Erath possesses the instinct to return continually to the relationships between the characters. Whenever theatre about theatre threatens to become an end in itself, Faust, Marguerite, and Méphistophélès reappear. Emotion rescues the concept. Not always the other way around. More importantly, however, the profoundly human dimension of Gounod’s opera never disappears from view. Beyond the metatheatrical games, the performance remains a drama about love, seduction, guilt, and sacrifice. This ability to balance intellectual concept and direct emotional impact may well constitute one of the major achievements of the Milan production.


Et Satan conduit le bal


Returning to the relationships on stage, the characters no longer appear as mere figures from a familiar story but as identities engaged in a continual negotiation with their own limits. No one possesses definitive control. The pact does not establish a stable hierarchy between master and victim; rather, it sets in motion a system of successive imbalances in which relations of power shift constantly. Whoever dominates in one moment immediately discovers their own vulnerability.


Méphistophélès remains the one who sets the machinery of temptation into motion and offers Faust the illusion of a new existence. Yet Faust never truly succeeds in escaping his own condition. The youth he regains alters his appearance, but not the deeper structure of his character. Paradoxically, even the broker of the pact seems trapped within a role from which he cannot escape. Condemned to provoke, seduce, and manipulate, Méphistophélès becomes a prisoner of his own dramatic function. He is compelled to direct the spectacle endlessly, to animate an entire gallery of demonic accomplices, and to sustain the illusion of absolute control. The moment one participant refuses the rules of the game, the mechanism begins to tremble. Marguerite, seemingly the most fragile of the characters, becomes the hardest to persuade. Her strength resides neither in seduction nor in authority, but in her capacity to preserve an inner core inaccessible to the influence of others. The greater the pressure exerted upon her, the more evident her autonomy becomes.


The circus world constitutes the most spectacular visual expression of this directorial concept. Each character receives a parallel identity that either reveals or distorts their essence. Marguerite becomes a tightrope walker suspended above the void, an image of perpetual balance under constant threat. Valentin appears as a white clown, guardian of an order beneath which he himself eventually collapses. Méphistophélès passes through a succession of masks and disguises that suggest the mobility of evil and its ability to assume whatever form becomes necessary. And Faust? He seems the only figure who never truly acquires a new identity. His costume, covered with formulas, calculations, and scientific notations like a blackboard worn upon his own body, opens and closes the performance virtually unchanged. The top hat he receives in the first act, at the moment of transformation, functions more as an accessory of illusion than as a sign of genuine metamorphosis. The mimes and acrobats do not serve as mere decorative embellishments but as projections of the inner conflicts of the principal characters, transforming the stage into a vast landscape of the subconscious.


This perspective also converges with the musical reading proposed by Daniele Rustioni. Under his baton, the La Scala Orchestra constructs an autonomous dramaturgical plane, at times contradicting what the characters express, at others revealing what they cannot articulate in song. The sonic world appears to possess a knowledge that surpasses the consciousness of those who inhabit it. Rustioni does not limit himself to accompanying the vocal discourse; he develops a remarkably original interpretation of the score in which Gounod’s music acquires a function that extends far beyond the mere support of words. A distinct sound world emerges, traversed by a constant internal agitation, in which language gradually detaches itself from its explanatory role and acquires expressive freedom of its own. The audience’s applause rewarded this musical discourse with ecstatic enthusiasm.


Much of the dramatic tension in Gounod’s score reveals itself precisely through the distance between what the characters declare and what the orchestra allows to emerge. Faust’s declarations of love, for example, preserve the appearance of purity on the textual level, while the orchestra introduces impatience, fever, impulse, and desire into the subtext. Beneath the vocal cantilena, the discreet pulse of the cellos and double basses sustains a latent restlessness, while clarinets and oboes colour the musical discourse with inflections suggesting fascination and hesitation. It is this discrepancy between verbal expression and sonic truth that generates much of the evening’s emotional depth.


On the podium, Rustioni discovers this approach through the relaxation of the conducting gesture itself. Freedom allows him to explore shades and expressive resources that guide, question, enrich, and sometimes even contradict the vocal line. Elsewhere, by contrast, the conductor seeks a compact sonority with an almost tactile consistency, particularly audible in the Marguerite-Faust duet and in the Act IV quartet. The violins shape broad melodic arches, while violas and cellos provide the orchestral fabric with velvety density. The woodwinds seem to prolong the emotions of the characters beyond language itself. The sound remains rich but rarely oppressive.


This interpretative freedom is not without its risks. During the Walpurgis Night scene, the emphasis on the timpani occasionally pushes the sonority toward the limits of excess, deliberately destabilising the orchestral balance and lending the episode an almost brutal energy. The brass reinforce this impression through interventions that are both brilliant and cutting, while the percussion becomes the true engine of dramatic tension. It is a debatable choice, but one justified by the internal logic of the sequence, whose unsettling character is thereby intensified without contradicting Gounod’s intentions.


Ultimately, the alternation between the force of accent and the refinement of orchestral colour defines Rustioni’s conducting approach. The orchestra is not reduced to accompaniment, yet neither does it become a rival to the stage. The same relationship between appearance and depth reappears in the construction of innocence itself. Nowhere is this transformation more evident than in the famous Jewel Song. Beneath its melodic grace, vanity gradually insinuates itself, without entirely erasing the initial purity. It merely begins to colour it. Flutes and clarinets capture Marguerite’s growing fascination with her own image, while the brilliance of the violins seems to accompany the emergence of a self-awareness that the character herself does not yet fully recognise.


The final scene impresses precisely because it refuses a spectacular climax. Instead of offering a grand dramatic release, Rustioni follows Gounod’s preference for restraint and spiritual illumination. There is none of the devastating pathos associated with the great Romantic tragedies; rather, there is a gradual purification of the orchestral discourse, in which the sonic mass slowly thins, making room for the transcendent dimension of the conclusion. Faust’s failure unfolds not through a cry but through a bitter withdrawal, supported by the gravity of the strings and the discreet interventions of the woodwinds. The music refuses to provide easy satisfactions or impose an immediate emotional conclusion. In place of resolution remains a silence that does not end with the performance itself. In Faust, Rustioni thus illuminates the innovative qualities of Gounod’s musical language without losing sight of its Romantic lineage.


In this construction, the Coro del Teatro alla Scala, prepared by Alberto Malazzi, becomes one of the most convincing expressions of communication between pit and stage. In Erath’s reading, the chorus represents not only the community of the characters but also the community of the spectators. The boundary between observer and participant becomes increasingly blurred, and this oscillation grants the ensemble a dramaturgical function extending far beyond its traditional role. Projected into the scenic mechanism devised by the director, it becomes simultaneously observer and participant, a multitude that watches, judges, and ultimately finds itself absorbed into its own spectacle.


From a musical perspective, the chorus stands out above all through the clarity of its French diction and the precision of its attacks. Even more impressive, however, is the way Malazzi and Rustioni articulate the constant dialogue between chorus and orchestra. The strings frequently support the choral discourse through an elastic and discreet pulse, while interventions from the woodwinds and brass contribute to defining a shared sonic space in which text and orchestration preserve their autonomy without losing contact with one another. The balance between pit and stage allows each collective intervention to retain both its dramatic force and the clarity of its musical architecture.


In Ainsi que la brise légère, the celebrated waltz of Act II, Rustioni avoids the temptation of decorative elegance and instead emphasises the page’s profound ambiguity. Beneath the dancing suppleness of the phrases there constantly lurks a sense of instability that already foreshadows the future imbalances of the drama. In Vin ou bière, bière ou vin, the scenic exuberance imagined by the director finds its counterpart in a mobile and alert orchestra that absorbs the rhythmic impulse of the voices and transforms it into a genuine mechanism of exaltation. The chorus does not simply illustrate Erath’s fairground world but contributes decisively to its creation alongside the orchestra.


Likewise, in Gloire immortelle de nos aïeux, the compactness and discipline of the chorus are amplified by the orchestral energy without the resulting sound ever becoming triumphalist. Rustioni avoids excessive monumentality, favouring instead a gradual build-up of tension in which voices and orchestra seem to breathe together. Erath’s characters inhabit an artificial universe with fairground overtones, where theatrical convention is constantly exposed. The chorus participates actively in this unveiling of theatre itself. It belongs simultaneously to the world of fiction and to that of representation, and this intermediate position grants it a unique status. Music does not exhaust the meanings of theatre. It organises them, amplifies them, and offers a perspective that at times surpasses even the limits of the stage image itself.


In the final tableau, however, the relationship between these two dimensions changes radically. Until that point, the chorus belongs equally to action and representation. In the conclusion, it detaches itself from the scenic space proper. The voices no longer emanate from the community visible before the audience, but from a space situated beyond the image itself. The chorus thus becomes autonomous from the stage and assumes the function of an authority transcending the circus world imagined by Erath. It is precisely within this tension between the visible and the invisible, between what is seen and what is heard, that the production’s two principal readings seem finally to converge.


More than that, the spectator’s attention is constantly shifted away from the unfolding of the legend itself toward the mechanisms by which that legend is represented. Opposites do not exclude one another but coexist and reflect each other continuously. The mirroring of the auditorium within the set introduces a second level of interpretation: theatre contemplates its own image. The audience no longer watches only the performance but is drawn into it. Méphistophélès appears to direct the game, Marguerite finds her balance in perpetual motion, and Faust attempts to recover the illusion of control over his own destiny.


Yet beyond the ingenuity of the scenic construction, the performance raises an essential question: who truly occupies the centre of the drama?


Listening closely to the score and observing the consistency of the stage choices, it becomes evident that the true dramatic axis is not only the relationship between Faust and Méphistophélès, but also that between Marguerite and Méphistophélès. Between innocence and temptation unfolds the opera’s fundamental conflict. She does not triumph over evil through strength but through her inability to become anything other than herself. Faust increasingly becomes the catalyst for a struggle that exceeds him. He is less the engine of the tragedy than the terrain upon which it unfolds. He does not truly decide; rather, he absorbs and reflects the tensions between two opposing forces. Faust becomes the pretext.


Il était un roi de Thulé, qui jusqu'à la tombe fidèle


This shift of emphasis is also reflected in Vittorio Grigolo’s construction of the title role. From a directorial standpoint, Faust remains the scholar striving to decipher the mechanism of the world into which he has been thrown. In Erath’s circus universe he briefly becomes a master of ceremonies, initiating the action without ever fully identifying with the role assigned to him. He observes, hesitates, negotiates, resists. While the other characters appear absorbed by the conventions of the spectacle, Faust always retains something of the fascinated and uneasy participant in his own experiment. He is not the master of the game, but perhaps the only character who genuinely seeks to understand its rules.


From this perspective, the world surrounding him acquires the appearance of a mechanism whose meanings are only partially accessible to him. What remains for others a succession of events, masks, and conventions seems to conceal for Faust a secret order that he strives, unsuccessfully, to decipher. The director develops this idea through the constant presence of doubles. Characters observe themselves from the outside, project themselves into their own past or future, and become in turn both subject and object of the gaze. Faust encounters his own alter ego, the elderly Faust, who returns as the spectre of a destiny that refuses to disappear with regained youth.


Grigolo neither rewrites the role nor attempts to modernise it artificially. On the contrary, he embraces it confidently, remaining close to the classical conception of the character, at least at the beginning of the performance. The Italian tenor continues to regard Faust as a kind of artistic fate. Hence perhaps the impression that he is playing himself. Nothing could be further from the truth. He does not confuse himself with the character; rather, he appears haunted by him. Faust consumes him, astonishes him, and continually challenges him. One often has the impression that the artist avoids offering definitive answers about the character precisely because the role continues to oppose him through its contradictions, the instability of its desires, and its resistance to reduction to a single identity.


What Grigolo offers instead is a profound understanding of the position occupied by Faust both within the economy of the drama and within the broader reflection on the human condition. The tenor seems to have climbed yet another step in his understanding of the role without ever pretending to have exhausted it. It is precisely this anxiety of continual searching that makes the interpretation so alive.


The impression nevertheless remains that the artist understands Faust’s emotional trajectory better than his metaphysical contradictions. Fascination, exaltation, desire, and despair are communicated superbly, but the tension between the man of science and the man of passion, between lucidity and surrender, emerges less frequently. The audience follows the hero’s development with interest, yet without feeling that his inner mystery has been completely conquered. After more than a decade of coexistence with the role, Grigolo inhabits it with familiarity but still does not dominate it completely.


Furthermore, the extraordinary spontaneity that constitutes one of the tenor’s greatest strengths can occasionally become a limitation. Expressive impulse sporadically prevails over the overall architecture, and the character fragments into a succession of local emotional truths without always acquiring the unity of a great tragic construction.


The opening musical interventions are built upon a deliberately restrained vocal production. Heroic vocalism is avoided, and the temptation to transform the character immediately into an expansive Romantic tenor is resisted. The phrase advances supported by discreet accents and a narrow, rigorously controlled vibrato. The middle register acquires a dark patina, while the carefully nuanced French diction reinforces the reflective dimension of the discourse. The Goethean titan disappears, leaving the solitude of a man who has exhausted knowledge without discovering the essential answer. Here lies Grigolo’s artistic signature. He does not possess the character, nor does he attempt to transform him into an extension of his own stage personality. He serves him. He investigates him. He plays him.


Rien! becomes more than a word. It becomes an existential diagnosis. Here the benefits of his collaboration with Rustioni are evident. The orchestra breathes alongside the character, and silences acquire almost as much significance as sounds. The attention paid to verbal colour remains remarkable. Merveille! never means exactly the same thing. At different moments it expresses astonishment, fascination, admiration, or almost childlike exaltation. The same is true of Marguerite’s name, which passes successively through the registers of discovery, desire, obsession, and despair.


The transformation begins with À moi les plaisirs, à moi les jeunes maîtresses! The tenor completely alters the energy of the vocal discourse. The rhythm becomes animated, the phrase acquires an almost uncontrollable impulse, and the sound gradually brightens. This is not the authentic exuberance of youth but the euphoria of a man rediscovering the possibility of youth.


The encounter with Marguerite provides perhaps the finest portion of the interpretation. Donne-moi ton bras ceases to be merely a gesture of courtesy. Grigolo does not portray a self-assured seducer. He does not conquer. He allows himself to be conquered. The entire scene is built upon reaction and listening. The character follows Marguerite’s gestures, searches for her gaze, and transforms every response she gives him into a revelation, particularly in the Act III duet.


All of this construction leads naturally toward Salut! demeure chaste et pure. Marguerite seems to leave the stage itself. Grigolo projects her into the auditorium, silently assigning her to every spectator willing to accept the convention of the moment. The phrase opens generously, the breath sustains broad arches, and the singing acquires the character of a confession addressed to an ideal rather than to a person. He allows the nuances to integrate gradually into the fabric of the phrase, permitting the sound to settle naturally, without haste or ostentation, into the resonances of the chest. Within such a context, the climactic high C becomes more than a technical challenge. Up to that point the vocal production remains free and luminous, yet the approach to the famous note introduces a slight additional tension within the vocal mechanism. The note is achieved, but it never entirely abandons itself to resonance. It is one of the few moments in which the technical construction becomes visible. Precisely for that reason, the moment demands a degree of scrutiny proportional to the beauty of the intention. And this Marguerite cannot forgive the tenor that compromise.


Walpurgis Night confirms that the true obsession of this Faust is neither youth, nor pleasure, nor even the pact itself. It is Marguerite. Cleopatra, Helen, and the other female figures appear merely as successive manifestations of the same image. Indeed, she receives more references than any other character throughout the performance. Méphistophélès watches from a distance with the lucidity of a strategist who no longer needs to intervene. Faust searches continually for the same woman. Marguerite appears, disappears, and returns in different forms. Between her and the devil there develops a troubling complicity. One demands his soul. The other claims it with equal force.


It is therefore in the final scene that this interpretation acquires its full significance. After an entire night spent among shadows and deceptive apparitions, Faust finds himself for the first time confronting reality. Here Grigolo effectively performs the abyss itself. The voice fractures expressively, accents become feverish, and the phrase seems pushed to the limits of emotional endurance. At that moment the character no longer seeks glory, youth, or pleasure. He seeks only Marguerite. He loses her in light.


In the final duet, in his last cry toward the angels who receive her into glory, there emerges not only the vocal culmination of the evening but the terminus of an inward journey. Faust finally understands what Méphistophélès had intuited from the beginning: his soul was not won through contract, but lost through love.


Divine pureté ! Chaste innocence, dont la puissance triomphe de ma volonté


Above Faust’s will rises the presence of Marguerite. Few contemporary sopranos seem as organically connected to this role as Marina Rebeka. In a production dominated by masks, doubles, and fluctuating identities, Marguerite preserves something essential: the coherence of a conscience. While Méphistophélès constantly changes the faces of temptation and Faust obsessively pursues his own reflections, Marguerite remains the only figure who traverses the entire dramatic construction without losing her moral centre. It is from this fidelity to herself that the opera’s true pole of resistance emerges.


The character created by Marina Rebeka is built through almost imperceptible nuances of vocal colour. Marguerite’s purity is not proclaimed but inscribed within the very substance of the sound. Broad breathing, a legato sustained with remarkable continuity, and an emission free of harshness or affectation establish from the outset the image of a being living in harmony with herself. What impresses immediately is the homogeneity of the entire vocal register. The transitions between registers occur naturally, without perceptible breaks, and the musical line retains its fluidity even during moments of tension. The soprano continuously shapes expansive arches of sound, allowing Gounod’s music to breathe in its own time.



Marina Rebeka as Marguerite – Faust at Teatro alla Scala (image adapted from the official trailer)
Marina Rebeka as Marguerite – Faust at Teatro alla Scala (image adapted from the official trailer)

This quality becomes apparent as early as Il était un roi de Thulé. The aria is often treated as little more than a prelude to the famous Jewel Song. Marina Rebeka, however, restores its true dramatic function. The song becomes a mirror in which Marguerite unknowingly discovers her own destiny. The vocal production remains centred and evenly supported throughout the line, while the French text is shaped with a delicacy that allows the music to flow naturally. One senses here a form of control so subtle that it occasionally filters emotion through the refinement of the construction itself. Certain inflections seem weighed with meticulous care down to the smallest detail. Yet this reserve serves the character. Marguerite lives deeply rather than demonstratively. Every emotion follows its slow path toward maturation.


In the celebrated Jewel Song, Rebeka achieves that precarious equilibrium between innocence and fascination that many interpretations sacrifice in favour of one of its two dimensions. The voice retains an almost childlike luminosity while gradually allowing awareness of personal beauty to emerge. Marguerite contemplates the jewels left by Méphistophélès and discovers her own image reflected in their brilliance. The coloratura is articulated with precision, the upper register opens freely, and the vocal agility avoids any trace of virtuosic display for its own sake. Everything appears to arise naturally from the character’s astonishment.


While Méphistophélès sets the machinery of temptation in motion, Marguerite answers him through a resistance free from theatrical grandstanding or overt gestures. This invisible confrontation lies at the very centre of the drama. As the fascination exerted by the objects gradually takes hold, Rebeka introduces almost imperceptible fissures into the character’s original transparency. The audience witnesses the slow birth of self-awareness, the true nucleus of Marguerite’s transformation. From this perspective, Rebeka and Alex Esposito create one of the evening’s most subtle relationships. Direct confrontation between them occurs only rarely, yet the presence of each continually shapes the trajectory of the other. Their tension develops above all in the unseen spaces of the drama, where temptation and self-knowledge begin to speak the same language.


The artist’s greatest achievement lies in the way she traces the gradual deterioration of Marguerite’s inner equilibrium through delicate modifications of vocal colour, through shadows that slowly emerge within the sound itself, through those moments when the voice seems briefly to lose its original transparency. The transformation remains fundamentally subterranean. It insinuates itself rather than announcing itself. As a result, the Church Scene and the great confrontations of the final act appear as the natural consequence of a process that began much earlier. The soprano follows every stage of this inner disintegration with remarkable rigor. The voice, once luminous and evenly balanced, acquires new densities, while dramatic accents are administered with economy and intelligence. Everything is measured with restraint; expression never loses its sense of inevitability.


When she finally reaches the invocation Anges purs, anges radieux, the character seems very far removed from the young woman who sang the legend of the King of Thule. And yet the same inner unity binds these two figures together. The voice now bears the marks of suffering, but it preserves intact the character’s essential dignity. Here lies the performance’s true achievement. The moment Marguerite’s musical line begins to fracture, it is in fact the very heart of the opera that fractures with it.


In the Latvian soprano’s interpretation, the final victory appears less as a triumph than as the quiet resistance of a conscience that, despite every wound, succeeds in preserving its inner integrity. The emotion produced by this Marguerite therefore stems less from admiration than from recognition. Before us stands neither a symbol nor an unattainable ideal. Before us stands a soul. In this recognition of human fragility resides one of the highest forms of truth that theatre can attain.


It is precisely this perfection of means, however, that gives rise to the principal reservation. Marina Rebeka controls the character with almost absolute rigor, yet that artistic discipline occasionally filters emotion through a perceptible layer of self-control. Marguerite consistently impresses, but she does not always unsettle. There are moments when the beauty of the vocal construction seems to prevail over emotional risk. The character is admired before she is pitied. Certain dramatic pages call for abandonment, while Rebeka often chooses mastery instead. It is the choice of a great and profoundly accomplished artist; it is not necessarily the most devastating choice available for Marguerite.


Orbiting around this dramatic axis is Siebel, portrayed by Marcela Rahal. In Johannes Erath’s interpretation, the character transcends the traditional function of the hopelessly enamoured youth and comes to resemble a mirror image of Valentin. If Marguerite’s brother conceals his vulnerability beneath the code of honour and duty, Siebel expresses precisely the sensitivity Valentin struggles to suppress. The two characters thus function as complementary projections of the same consciousness. Rahal makes intelligent use of this dramaturgical position through a stage presence free of sentimental affectation. Her dark, velvety timbre endows the character with particular warmth, while the elegant phrasing maintains a constant sense of proportion. Both vocally and dramatically, the artist creates a presence that is discreet yet firm, capable of drawing attention without ostentatiously demanding it. Siebel consequently emerges as a sensitive witness to the tragedy in preparation, a constant presence whose strength resides precisely in its refusal of easy effect.


À toi, Seigneur, je la confie


In striking contrast to the instability of identity that dominates Johannes Erath’s universe, Alex Esposito’s Méphistophélès is defined by a remarkable unity of conception. His vocal discourse possesses clarity, precision, and a technical command that transforms each intervention into an act of authority. The character appears to know in advance the possible trajectories of everyone around him and to manipulate from the shadows the mechanisms governing their existence.


Yet it is precisely this certainty that becomes the source of the character’s most compelling ambiguities. Beneath the permanently controlled elegance of the surface, one occasionally senses an unease that briefly cracks the perfection of the mask. In such moments, the demon ceases to be merely a force of temptation and becomes aware of his own limitations.

Esposito’s artistic intelligence manifests itself most strikingly in ensemble passages. His voice consistently preserves the clarity of the text and the coherence of dramatic intention without disturbing the collective architecture of the scene. His presence dominates not through sheer volume but through inner density. Every appearance contributes to the gradual construction of a figure who understands the mechanisms of the human soul and knows how to exploit every weakness he encounters.


Vocally, the artist deliberately avoids the temptation of building Méphistophélès exclusively upon the opulence of the lower register. The vocal production remains flexible and mobile, while his French diction benefits from an almost instrumental clarity. Yet this elegance of phrasing occasionally reduces the sense of disturbing sonic substance that great interpreters of the role have imposed upon the French tradition. The middle register privileges intellectual control over menace, while the lower range impresses above all through its cohesion and technical mastery rather than through any elemental force.


In Le Veau d'Or, this conception arguably reaches its culmination. Vocal virtuosity and theatrical instinct meet here in an almost ideal balance. The character’s now emblematic laughter acquires its true dramatic function: to mark the triumph of an intelligence that views the world as a vast spectacle of desires. Méphistophélès appears simultaneously seductive and threatening, ironic and implacable, like a consciousness that knows the exact price of every human weakness.


One of the most interesting cultural intuitions of the interpretation resides precisely here. Esposito departs from the Romantic image of Absolute Evil and instead constructs a Méphistophélès rooted in modern lucidity. He is not the demon who dominates the world through violence, but the one who understands it better than anyone else. His power derives from his ability to identify the fissures within human consciousness and to speak the language of its hidden desires. In this sense, the character seems closer to the great sceptical figures of modern European culture than to the traditional embodiment of infernal power.


What occasionally remains absent from this admirably controlled construction is the feeling of genuine danger. Méphistophélès fascinates, seduces, mocks, and frequently entertains, but he rarely truly disturbs. Esposito creates a demon of intelligence and refinement rather than one of metaphysical vertigo. The audience almost constantly admires him without ever entirely fearing him. In a production that insists upon the limits of his power, such an approach may be dramaturgically justified. Yet at certain moments one misses that dimension of unpredictability that transforms a great Méphistophélès into a genuinely threatening presence.


From this perspective, the pact between Faust and Méphistophélès undergoes a profound shift in meaning. The emphasis moves away from the classical theme of selling one’s soul toward the problem of identity itself. Faust gains access to a new existence, to youth, love, and experiences he believed lost. Yet each of these gifts remains filtered through the same consciousness that contemplates them. Within this universe, Valentin occupies a special position. If Faust represents the field upon which temptation acts, Valentin represents its first limit. The character emerges as a nucleus of moral uprightness in a world where identities fragment and lose their coherence. For this reason, his conflict with Méphistophélès transcends the level of a simple dramatic confrontation and acquires symbolic value.


Ernesto Petti gives vocal expression to this dimension with remarkable nobility. The beauty of the timbre, the richness of its harmonic spectrum, and the naturalness of the phrasing suggest from the outset the existence of a character living in an authentic relationship with his own values. The vocal line unfolds with breadth and balance, while the attention devoted to the text transforms every intervention into an affirmation of a moral order under siege. Valentin’s death therefore becomes one of the performance’s centres of gravity. The white clown collapses in the arena he had been summoned to govern, and the image acquires the force of a parable. Méphistophélès’ victory over man is incontestable at the level of events. On the spiritual plane, however, the scene suggests something altogether different: the existence of a reality that the demon may wound but can never absorb.


Here lies the character’s true significance. Valentin does not represent the victory of good over evil but rather the impossibility of evil ever fully exhausting the moral truth of a human existence. Death removes him from the world of the spectacle, yet simultaneously confirms the very integrity that Méphistophélès seeks to destroy. The beauty of Petti’s voice amplifies this impression and transforms the death scene into a moment of genuine tragic gravity.

If Vittorio Grigolo offers the evening’s most complex character, Marina Rebeka its moral centre, and Alex Esposito the sceptical consciousness observing and orchestrating the destinies of all the others, Ernesto Petti arguably provides the most complete artistic achievement of the performance. Nothing appears excessive, nothing insufficient. Voice, word, phrase, and stage presence converge toward the same idea of theatrical truth. Valentin appears less frequently than the other protagonists, yet every intervention creates the impression of absolute dramatic necessity. In a production dominated by reflections on identity and representation, Petti achieves the rare feat of making the character exist without requiring further explanation.


Marthe, portrayed by Hyeonsol Park, discreetly and effectively completes the ensemble imagined by Erath. Her precise and carefully measured stage presence supports the coherence of the dramatic universe without drawing disproportionate attention to a role whose function remains secondary. In this way, the artist contributes significantly to the overall balance of the production. Xhieldo Hyseni’s Wagner fulfils a similarly supportive function. Although the role offers limited opportunities for individual development, the bass-baritone brings vocal firmness and theatrical discipline to his appearances, ensuring that even the smaller dramatic components remain fully integrated into the production’s carefully constructed ecosystem.


Viewed together, these characters reveal the true nature of Méphistophélès’ power. He does not create desire. He merely gives it language, form, and direction. His power does not lie in inventing human passions but in setting them into motion and accelerating their development. The demon acts like a great director of energies that already exist.


And this is perhaps the true subject of Johannes Erath’s production. The limits of evil are not defined by the strength of good, but by the impossibility of any power wholly occupying the inner space of a human being. Faced with this mystery, even Méphistophélès discovers that dominion over the world remains fundamentally different from dominion over the soul.


Viens, c'est moi qui te l'ordonne ! Marguerite.


Marguerite defeats Méphistophélès. The moment the chorus proclaims the Resurrection, salvation ceases to function as a dramatic resolution and becomes another form of rebirth. Marguerite’s journey reaches fulfilment precisely where Méphistophélès discovers the limits of his power. She represents the boundary beyond which his authority can no longer operate. Yet the entire scene remains faithful to the circus convention. The objects remain exposed, the characters retain their positions, and the theatrical universe continues to exist even at the very moment of redemption. Nothing collapses. Nothing is suspended. The game goes on. It is precisely this continuity that gives the image such force.


Faust now seems to have been merely the pretext for a deeper confrontation. Beyond the familiar pact emerges a second, unspoken pact between Marguerite and Méphistophélès. He offers her the world. She opposes him with faith. He controls the machinery of the spectacle. She escapes its logic.


Faust’s double remains beside Faust himself. Together they bend over the cup from which his own poison is consumed, in a gesture reminiscent of initiation, sacrifice, or condemnation. At the very same moment, the music proclaims the triumph of the Resurrection. Death and salvation occupy the same stage simultaneously.


The suspended metal structure preserves its ambiguity until the very end. Circus apparatus, scaffold, theatrical mechanism, place of execution: it refuses to settle into a single meaning. The circus figures witness the conclusion like spectators attending the final image of a performance. They watch. They wait. Their mere presence confirms that everything has been theatre and that theatre continues.


At the centre of this world, Marguerite moves toward the spectre of light. Her movement seems directed by a force that lies beyond the earthly conventions of the stage. For the first time, she belongs neither to the circus nor even entirely to the story itself.


Méphistophélès remains behind, his arms open in a gesture that evokes both surrender and, inevitably, the image of crucifixion. The position of his body suggests the recognition of a force against which he cannot prevail. His power over the world remains intact. His power over Marguerite comes to an end.


Faust remains suspended between the two destinies. The arm raised toward the heights retains something of the restlessness of a man who continues to seek. Salvation, transcendence, meaning: all appear to exist at the same immeasurable distance.


The final image, however, belongs to Méphistophélès. Seated in the chair from Row Three, like a spectator who arrived too late, he closes the representation. The director of the game becomes its observer:“Imagine yourself a spectator in the world, as though at the theatre.”

Faust collapses, together with his soul. Marguerite redeems him

Faust by Charles GounodTeatro alla Scala, 8 November 2026
Faust by Charles GounodTeatro alla Scala, 8 November 2026

 
 
 

Comentarii

Evaluat(ă) cu 0 din 5 stele.
Încă nu există evaluări

Adaugă o evaluare

© 2026 profficer.org | Paula Margareta Luca

bottom of page